Everton F.C. vs Arsenal F.C. Timeline – Head-to-Head History and Stats

The rivalry between Everton and Arsenal stands as one of the longest-running fixtures in English football history, with over 115 years of competitive encounters stretching back to 1909. Across 227 total matches in all competitions, Arsenal has established a dominant position in this historic pairing, though Everton has produced memorable upsets along the way. The two clubs have met in high-stakes Premier League battles, FA Cup ties, and league encounters that have shaped title races and relegation battles alike.

This timeline traces the evolution of the Everton-Arsenal rivalry from their first competitive meeting through to recent Premier League fixtures. The data reveals patterns of dominance, periods of resistance, and the key moments that have defined this fixture across multiple decades of English football.

What is the Head-to-Head Record Between Everton and Arsenal?

Arsenal holds a commanding position in the all-time head-to-head record against Everton. Across 227 competitive matches, the Gunners have secured 114 victories, representing a win rate of approximately 50.2 percent. Everton has claimed 65 wins, accounting for 28.6 percent of meetings, while 48 matches have ended in draws, making up 21.1 percent of the total fixtures.

The goal difference heavily favors Arsenal, with the North London club scoring 374 goals compared to Everton’s 265 across the entirety of their competitive history. This averages approximately 2.8 goals per match across all competitions, indicating a tendency toward entertaining, high-scoring encounters.

Premier League Record

Within Premier League competition specifically, Arsenal maintains a strong advantage. In a tracked dataset of recent top-flight encounters, Arsenal recorded 13 wins, 3 draws, and just 2 losses. The team scored 33 goals while conceding 20, averaging 1.83 goals per game with 59 percent average possession. Everton managed 8 wins alongside 7 losses in the same dataset, scoring 20 goals and conceding 33. Arsenal kept 9 clean sheets compared to Everton’s 8 during this period.

Home and Away Performance

The fixture reveals distinct characteristics depending on venue. At the Emirates Stadium, Arsenal has produced several emphatic victories, including a 5-1 win in February 2018, a 4-0 victory in March 2023, and a 2-1 triumph in May 2024. Everton’s Goodison Park has also proven a challenging venue for Arsenal, with the Toffees recording 1-0 wins in 2023 and April 2021, along with 2-1 victories in 2020 and 2021.

• Arsenal has won 31 of 51 tracked matches across home and away venues
• Everton recorded 9 wins in the same 51-match dataset
• Arsenal’s goal tally in these matches reached 97 compared to Everton’s 41
• Since 1995, Arsenal has won 42 of 66 matches against Everton

Historical Timeline of Everton vs Arsenal Matches

The first recorded meeting between the two clubs occurred on October 23, 1909, when Woolwich Arsenal defeated Everton 1-0 in a League Division One fixture. This inaugural encounter took place at a time when Arsenal had only recently gained top-flight status, making Everton’s defeat a notable result in early rivalry history.

Everton’s response came swiftly. Less than four months later, on February 5, 1910, the Toffees recorded their largest victory in the fixture with a 5-0 triumph over Woolwich Arsenal in an FA Cup tie. This remains one of the most significant margins of victory for either club in their shared history.

Decade-by-Decade Overview

The rivalry has evolved considerably across different eras of English football. During the 1960s Division One era, Everton proved competitive, including a notable 3-1 victory in 1965. The 1990s brought mixed results, with both clubs sharing points in matches such as a 0-0 draw in 1993 and a 1-1 result in 1994, while Arsenal claimed victories including 2-0 wins in both 1992 and 1993.

The 2010s saw Arsenal establish stronger dominance in the fixture. Convincing victories included a 5-1 home win in February 2018 and a remarkable 2-5 away triumph in October 2017. However, Everton demonstrated their capacity for upset results, securing a 1-0 victory at Goodison Park in April 2019.

The 2020s have continued the pattern of Arsenal superiority, with the Gunners winning 8 of 16 Premier League meetings during this decade. Everton managed 4 victories while 4 matches ended in draws. Arsenal’s recent dominance includes a seven-match winning streak in Premier League encounters before results became more evenly balanced.

Recent Everton vs Arsenal Results

Recent Premier League fixtures between the clubs have demonstrated Arsenal’s growing ascendancy, particularly since 2022. The Gunners secured a commanding 5-1 victory in May 2022 and followed this with a 4-0 win in March 2023. These results reflected Arsenal’s improved form under their current management and the strengthening of their squad.

However, Everton has shown resistance, particularly at Goodison Park. In September 2023, Everton claimed a 1-0 victory away from home. The fixture pattern then shifted toward more competitive encounters, with a 2-1 Arsenal win in May 2024 keeping the Gunners’ Premier League title ambitions alive during a tightly contested race against Manchester City.

Last Ten Premier League Encounters

More recent results show the momentum shifting decisively toward Arsenal. December 2024 brought a 0-0 draw at Goodison Park, while April 2025 ended 1-1. Most recently, Arsenal secured a 1-0 victory on December 20, 2025, at Goodison Park, continuing their recent dominance in this fixture.

Biggest Victories and Key Moments in Everton vs Arsenal History

Several matches stand out as defining moments in this rivalry’s history. Everton’s 5-0 FA Cup victory in February 1910 remains the largest margin of victory for either club in the fixture. This result came during the formative years of the rivalry and established Everton as capable of producing emphatic performances against their North London opponents.

For Arsenal, the 5-1 victories have become synonymous with their dominance in recent decades. The February 2018 Emirates win, October 2017 away triumph as 2-5, and May 2022 Premier League victory all demonstrated Arsenal’s attacking capability against Everton. A 4-0 victory in March 2023 further emphasized this superiority.

Matches Influencing Title Races

The May 2024 encounter proved particularly significant in the context of Premier League title competition. Arsenal’s 2-1 victory away to Everton kept their championship hopes alive during the final stages of the season. Though Arsenal ultimately fell short in the title race to Manchester City, this result demonstrated the fixture’s capacity to influence major outcomes.

High-Scoring Encounters

The fixture has produced numerous high-scoring spectacles that remain memorable for fans of both clubs. The 5-1 Arsenal victories in 2018 and 2022 showcased clinical finishing and defensive vulnerability. The 2-5 Arsenal win in October 2017 represented one of their most dominant away performances in this fixture. A 3-2 Arsenal victory in February 2020 provided dramatic late-game action that encapsulated the unpredictable nature of Premier League football.

Pre-season friendlies have also contributed to the fixture list, including an Arsenal 2-0 victory in July 2022. While these matches carry less competitive weight, they demonstrate the ongoing scheduling relationship between the clubs.

Timeline of Major Encounters

The following chronological overview highlights significant moments across the history of this fixture:

1. October 23, 1909 – Woolwich Arsenal defeats Everton 1-0 in the first competitive meeting between the clubs (League Division One)
2. February 5, 1910 – Everton records their largest victory with a 5-0 FA Cup win over Woolwich Arsenal
3. 1965 – Everton defeats Arsenal 3-1 in Division One during a period of competitive balance
4. 1992-1993 – Arsenal posts consecutive 2-0 victories during the early Premier League era
5. October 2017 – Arsenal produces a stunning 2-5 away victory at Goodison Park
6. February 2018 – Arsenal wins 5-1 at the Emirates Stadium in a dominant home performance
7. April 2021 – Everton secures a rare Emirates victory with a 1-0 win, their most recent success at Arsenal’s stadium
8. May 2022 – Arsenal extends dominance with a 5-1 Premier League victory
9. May 2024 – Arsenal’s 2-1 win keeps Premier League title race alive
10. December 2025 – Arsenal continues recent dominance with 1-0 away victory

Additional details on Premier League fixtures and historical match records can be found through Live Arsenal’s head-to-head database and 11v11’s opposition statistics.

What We Know and What Remains Uncertain

The historical record for this fixture contains areas of varying certainty. Comprehensive data exists for Premier League matches since the competition’s formation in 1992, with detailed statistics including goal scorers, attendance figures, and match events. Recent decades also benefit from extensive media coverage and official club archives.

Earlier decades, particularly the pre-war and interwar periods, contain less comprehensive documentation. While match results and basic scores are generally available, detailed statistics such as individual goal scorers, attendance figures, and tactical analyses become increasingly sparse for matches before the 1960s.

Understanding the Rivalry

The Everton-Arsenal fixture represents a clash between two founding members of English football’s top division. Everton, based in Liverpool, and Arsenal, representing North London, have maintained their status among England’s elite clubs throughout professional football’s history. This geographical and historical distance has contributed to a rivalry built more on competitive respect than local derby tensions.

Tactically, the fixture has evolved alongside changes in football philosophy. Earlier eras emphasized defensive organization and set-piece effectiveness, while modern encounters increasingly feature high pressing, possession-based football, and technical proficiency. Both clubs have adapted their approaches across different managers and playing generations.

The fixture has served various narrative purposes throughout Premier League history. For Arsenal, matches against Everton have represented opportunities to consolidate positions in title races or rebuild momentum following inconsistent periods. For Everton, these encounters have often served as indicators of their capacity to compete against top-tier opposition, with notable victories providing crucial confidence and momentum.

Sources and References

The data presented in this article draws from multiple verified sources specializing in football statistics and historical records. Sports Mole provides comprehensive head-to-head analysis including match-by-match results, venue details, and competitive context. WorldFootball.net offers detailed fixture information across multiple competitions and eras.

Premier League records indicate Arsenal’s continued dominance in recent seasons, with the club securing multiple consecutive victories against Everton in Premier League competition since 2022.

Additional verification comes from 11v11, which maintains detailed opposition profiles for clubs across English football history, and Live Arsenal’s dedicated head-to-head database. SoccerPunter and AiScore provide supplementary data confirming broader trends in the fixture across specified sample sizes.

Summary

The Everton vs Arsenal fixture encompasses 227 competitive matches spanning over 115 years of English football history. Arsenal holds a dominant position with 114 victories compared to Everton’s 65, alongside 48 draws. The Gunners have scored 374 goals to Everton’s 265 across all competitions, averaging nearly 2.8 goals per match. Premier League data specifically shows Arsenal winning 13 of 18 recent top-flight encounters, with notable victories including multiple 5-1 wins and a 4-0 triumph. While Everton demonstrated unexpected competitiveness between 2020 and 2023, winning four of five Premier League meetings, Arsenal’s overall historical advantage remains substantial. For broader football analysis, explore our coverage of Man City Transfer News – Summer 2024 Ins and Outs and Oklahoma City Thunder vs San Antonio Spurs Match Player Stats.

Frequently Asked Questions